• Regarding Concert Review

    Sunday 19th November 2023


    Garry Walker Conductor
    Moira Docherty Soprano
    Tara Leiper Alto


    Mikhail Verbytskyi (1851 – 1870)
    The National Anthem of Ukraine arr. John Hearne
    George Frideric Handel (1685 – 1759)
    Overture and Arrival of the Queen of Sheba from Solomon
    Antonio Vivaldi (1678 – 1741)
    Gloria in D RV589
    Ludwig van Beethoven (1770 – 1827)
    Symphony No. 3 in E flat op. 55 “Eroica”


    Aberdeen Sinfonietta were at their expected best for their Autumn Concert in Aberdeen's Music Hall. For this concert, they were to be joined by Con Anima Chamber Choir, bringing together the very best the City has to offer in both instrumental and choral music making. The upstairs in the Music Hall was well filled. Downstairs was all right but considering the quality of the performances we were about to enjoy, I would have been happy to see it packed. Nevertheless, there is nowhere else in Aberdeen that would have been able to accommodate Sunday's audience.
    As has been a regular feature of these concerts, the music began with The National Anthem of Ukraine and this year, with Con Anima in attendance onstage, the words of the Anthem were also sung. I was pleased that conductor Garry Walker asked us all to stand for the Anthem. In previous years, myself and a few others did stand, this year everyone did.
    Then, it was time for the concert proper to begin. The Overture from Handel's oratorio Solomon is quite extensive and in several parts. It was an opportunity for Sinfonietta's string players to show just what they could do. The playing was wonderfully clean, clear and well balanced. Blair Cargill added the spicing of harpsichord sound albeit on an electronic instrument. A pair of oboes were also there in the overture but it was in the Arrival of the Queen of Sheba that they had their moments centre stage as it were, and they were excellent. A sizzlingly fine performance indeed.
    As the late James Lobban wrote in his excellent note reproduced in Sunday's programme, Vivaldi's Gloria is in 12 sections beginning with the full chorus with strings oboe and trumpet, that latter played with considerable delicacy by Alan Haggart. The blend of instruments and chorus was perfectly well balanced, clean, bright and exhilarating. Our two female voice soloists Moira Docherty and Tara Leiper blended nicely in the Laudamus Te. Tara Leiper though an alto had to sing second soprano here and it worked pleasingly. In the Domine Deus soprano soloist Moira Docherty was supported by a delicious blend of oboe, harpsichord, cello and double bass. That was a highlight of the performance. Tara's first solo opened with a delightful cello solo played by Alison MacDonald, and you don't get better than that. The second alto solo had to contend with full orchestra but I think she did well. Throughout the work, orchestra and chorus were splendid and in the fugal ending, Cum Sancto Spiritu the music really took off brilliantly. Can I say that throughout the singing, the sopranos soared skyward magnificently and both tenors and basses were excellent. You don't always get that with some choirs but then Con Anima are special, being numerically perfectly well balanced.
    I have heard numerous performances of Beethoven's Eroica. Some of these have been heavy and wet so I was not sure what to expect. Well, Sunday's performance was conducted with real razzle-dazzle spirit by Garry Walker. He put his whole body into a sprightly, animated first movement that for me was a revelation. There were things that stood out in this performance that I had hardly noticed before, things that made sense in Beethoven's writing, things that had simply passed me by in some other performances. Throughout the symphony there were splendid moments of solo playing, horn, flutes and later clarinet. The strings were marvellous with melodies that swept past in that first movement almost as if we were in a fast train with the music whizzing past, and yet nothing was lost. The second movement was slower and as the programme note stated ‘with an almost tangible sense of deep tragedy' and yet, with the way in which Sinfonietta's strings delivered Beethoven's delicious melody, I could only feel optimistic.
    In the Scherzo, Sinfonietta's delightful horn trio took us out on a hunting expedition. There was a marvellous sense of the open air in this performance.
    For the final movement, Garry Walker brought back the full energy he had brought to the first movement of the Symphony. Every section of the orchestra excelled. Horns called out to the trumpets who replied and let's not forget the splendid Isabel John on timpani. That is a part of the orchestra in Beethoven's time that gives the music its very heartbeat along perhaps with the three double basses on Sunday. Above all, what contributed to the success of this particular performance was that the orchestra was exactly the right size.



  • Regarding CD Review
  • MADRIGALI: Fire and Roses - Con Anima Chamber Choir - Paul Mealor (Conductor) - 809730509421 - Released: October 2011 - Divine Art DDA25094
    Morten Lauridsen - Madrigali: Six 'fire songs' on Italian Renaissance poems
    Claudio Monteverdi - Se per havervi, oimè
    Carlo Gesualdo - Luci serene e chiare
    Vincenzo Ruffo - Lo piango
    Girolamo Scotto - Amor, io sento l'alma
    Yvo Barry - Quando son piu lontan
    Henricus Schaffen - Ov'è, lass', il bel viso?
    Paul Mealor - Now sleeps the crimson petal
    Anonymous - There is no rose
    John Ward - Upon a bank with roses set about
    John Wilbye - Lady, when I behold the roses
    Gustav Holst - Now sleeps the crimson petal
    James MacMillan - So deep
    Morten Lauridsen - Chanson éloignée

    A luminous collection of a cappella choral works spanning five centuries, the showpiece of which is the Now Sleeps the Crimson Petal cycle, by Paul Mealor himself, of which the first movement was personally chosen by Prince William and Kate Middleton (now the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge) as the musical centerpiece of the April 2011 Royal wedding service. An impressive choral work that superbly combines the clean and open harmonies of the Renaissance, with the more distant harmonic intervals of today, and sits within a pitch range that always serves the four individual voice parts extremely well. An evocative work that at times demands vocal gymnastics from the singers, but most of all commands a beauty and richness of sound too often absent from today's music.

    The Scottish Con Anima Chamber Choir is quickly establishing a reputation as a choral ensemble that can comfortably adapt to the various demands of music past and present, as evidenced on this new recording. From John Ward, to Gustav Holst, to Morten Lauridsen, their delivery enhances the music's character and style, and never sounds as if out of its element. The blend of voices from the basses to the sopranos is always in perfect equilibrium, and could be compared to a supple and malleable fabric that conductor Paul Mealor can easily mold and shape to fit the music at hand.

    The Divine Art sound recording has calibrated the distance between you and the choir very well, giving it a tangible and realistic feel that wraps you in a warm blanket of sound. You will understand what I mean when you hear the final chord of the Paul Mealor work.

    Jean-Yves Duperron - November 2011
    Classical Music Sentinel


    - Classical Music Sentinel


Brought to you by Making Music
Copyright © 2024 Con Anima